Star Wars 9is a big mystery right now. We still don’t even have a title from Lucasfilm and J.J. Abrams, leading to a little paranoia from hardcore fans. Thankfully, we have seen a few pretty solid leaks, one of which shows off Kylo Ren’s helmet pieced back together. This was something that was talked about pretty early on in the production process and recently leaked concept art shows that it has been fixed. However, this could lead to a pretty crazy plot twist.

Kylo Renhas had a difficult go in the latestStar Warstrilogy and has yet to truly find himself, though slicing Supreme Leader Snoke in half was a good start. InThe Last Jedi, Snoke poked fun at Ren’s helmet, which was a tribute to his heroDarth Vader. Out of frustration, the young villain, and leader of the Knights of Ren, decides to smash his helmet into pieces in a fit of rage. But now, it looks like that helmet is back forStar Wars 9, but what if it isn’t Kylo Ren wearing it?

A new theory suggests that Kylo Ren isn’t the one under thenew version of the helmet. But, who would take on the old mask and fix it up? There is speculation that it could be a disgruntled member of the Knights of Ren, who might be pretty angry at the fact that their leader killed Snoke. The Knights of Ren have yet to be officially confirmed forStar Wars 9, but it has been heavily rumored that they will appear and they will more than likely want to know what happened to their Supreme Leader.

It’s entirely possible that it could be someone else within the First Order who wants to make a point to Kylo Ren and undermine his new-found authority. However,Matt Smith has been cast in a mystery roleinStar Wars 9and there have been conflicting reports as to who exactly he is playing. The common belief for a while was that he was going to be in the Knights of Ren, which would make him a prime candidate to pick up the old mask and move forward, if this theory proves to be true.

Taking another helmet and impersonating a character is not unprecedented in theStar Warsuniverse. In the 1997 Boba Fett: Twin Engines of Destruction one-off comic, a bounty hunter named Jodo Kast took Boba Fett’s armor and impersonated the character as a way to make money. That would be a pretty interesting twist that a lot ofStar Warsfans don’t see coming in the final movie in the Skywalker saga. Obviously, this is just a rumor for the time being, but it is a pretty interesting theory. The latestStar Wars 9theory comes to us fromInverse.